People’s Choice: Best Pizza in Colorado Springs

The people have spoken. These are YOUR picks for the best pizza in the Springs. Compare them with our picks and go do your own taste test.

Is pizza the perfect food? It’s definitely a favorite food. And whether you’re a fan of New York style pizza (don’t miss our New York favorites here), Neapolitan, New Haven, Chicago, Sicilian, Roman, Detroit, wood-fired or deep dish, you can probably agree that pizza rules for an easy and delicious meal. What you might not agree on is who has the best pizza in Colorado Springs.

We gave one of our food experts the mission of highlighting 10 of the Best Pizza Joints in the Springs. But we wanted to know what you think, so we took a poll. Voters could choose from all of our picks or write in their own favorite. And now the people have spoken. Most of the winners came from our list, but Savelli’s, Fat Sully’s, Boriello Brothers, Il Vicino and Upstate Pizza all broke into the list. 

Poll Winners: The People’s Choice Best Pizza in Colorado Springs

1. Slice420

2. Leon Gessi New York Pizza

3. Walter’s 303

4. White Pie

5. Pizzeria Rustica

6. Basil & Barely

7. Stellina Pizza Cafe

8. Parry’s Pizzeria (tie)

8. Fat Sully’s (tie) 

8. Joey’s Pizza (tie)

11. Pies & Grinders

12. Savelli’s

13. High Rise Pizza Kitchen (tie)

13. Borriello Brothers (tie)

13. Il Vicino (tie)

13. Upstate Pizzeria (tie)

You can read more about our writer’s picks in 10 of the Best Pizza Joints in the Springs. There were 28 pizza restaurants that received votes in our People’s Choice poll, showing that there’s no shortage of options for pizza food out there. It also proves that diners have a wide variety of opinions, tastes and neighborhood favorites. If you still don’t see your favorite pizza joint or disagree with our picks and the People’s Choice picks, let us know. We’re always open for more yummy research. 

Serving a slice from a huge Fat Sully's New York Pizza
Huge slices and pies, that chewy New York style crust and late-night hours downtown make Fat Sully’s one of the People’s Choice picks for Best Pizza in Colorado Springs. Photo by Eli Epstein.

Of course, it’s hard to find a more perfect pairing with pizza than beer, so be sure to check out our Best Breweries in Colorado Springs.

And when you’re ready for dessert, pick your pleasure. Grab a cone or sundae at one of our best picks for The Best Ice Cream in Colorado Springs. Or choose a doughy delight with The Best Doughnuts in the Springs. 


Like this article and want to read more like it?

Sign up for the Springsmag.com newsletter and get the latest on the best restaurants, hiking trails and things to do in Colorado Springs delivered straight to your inbox.

Name

 

 

Jeremy Jones
Jeremy Jones
Jeremy Jones is Springs’ co-founder, editorial director and chief outdoor officer. He loves building community by telling stories about all the people, places and culture that make Colorado Springs an amazing place to live. And he’s especially stoked when exploring new places in the Springs, Colorado and beyond. Watch for him hiking, running or mountain biking the local trails with his wife and kids.

Follow Us On Social

RELATED ARTICLES

6 Reasons We Love the Mining Exchange Hotel

With historic charm and elevated style, The Mining Exchange provides a one-of-a-kind stay in the heart of downtown Colorado Springs. Here’s how.

5 Best Things to Do in Colorado Springs This Weekend

Top events and entertainment you don’t want to miss, including the Manitou wine festival, a free outdoor expo, everyone’s favorite astrophysicist and more.

Where to Find Farmers Markets in Colorado Springs

Want to eat local and fresh? Discover fresh produce, artisanal goods and a vibrant community of local growers and makers at these farmers markets.