What are the most popular restaurants in Colorado Springs? That depends on how you measure. One interesting metric is restaurant reservations, which leads us to an interesting look by OpenTable. The reservation app calculates a monthly list of Most Booked Restaurants in Colorado Springs based on user activity. It’s not a fully comprehensive analysis as not all restaurants use the app, not all restaurants require reservations and not all diners book a table ahead when they go out to eat. But we think it gives an interesting snapshot into the Colorado Springs restaurant scene. And it gives a heads-up for where you need to plan ahead for that big date night or special celebration dinner. We’re not surprised to see several restaurants crossing over from our own annual list of 30 Best Restaurants, plus some other local standouts as well.
That said, here’s the OpenTable list of Most Booked Restaurants in Colorado Springs at the end of 2024, with our own descriptions of these popular local restaurants. Be sure to book ahead for your reservations.
The Rabbit Hole
The chic, subterranean Rabbit Hole serves an interesting menu of upscale New American cuisine and likes to call itself the best kept secret in the Springs. We all know the secret is out.
Paravicini’s Italian Bistro
Romance, Old World decor, garlic aromas and a menu full of rich Italian classics keep this OCC hot spot on many people’s favorite lists. It’s always entertaining to catch owner and chef Franco Pisani in his element there too.
The Melting Pot
Whether it’s molten cheese or chocolate, fondue makes dining an experience that can be fun for families or groups and romantic for couples.
La Taverne
La Taverne delivers the fine dining steakhouse experience with Broadmoor elegance and a touch of French sophistication.
Cowboy Star
Cowboy Star blends upscale elegance and rustic charm into a classic Colorado dining experience. With its own butcher shop, the steakhouse consistently delivers excellent cuts of beef and wild game. It’s also one of our favorite happy hours in Colorado Springs.
MacKenzie’s Chop House
With a classic menu featuring steaks, seafood, martinis and more, Mack’s has been a cozy downtown go-to for happy hour, date night downtown or an after-the-show nightcap since 1997.
Glen Eyrie
Once home to city founders Gen. William J. and Queen Palmer, the Glen Eyrie castle is a Colorado Springs treasure. It’s the perfect setting for an afternoon high tea. (If it’s booked, find more options in our Tea Time in Colorado Springs.)
Ristorante Del Lago
Is that Cheyenne Lake or Lake Como? Del Lago at the Broadmoor transports you to exceptional lakeside dining.
Red Gravy
With Chef Eric Brenner at the helm, Red Gravy is a downtown gem for delicious Italian comfort food.
Prime 25
This chic Ivywild restaurant puts a stylishly modern spin on steak, seafood and cocktails. Expect a top-shelf experience.
