Anyone can attest that pizza ranks among one of the most beloved eats of all time, revered worldwide by folks of all ages as the choice grab-and-go meal. It acts as a reputable breakfast, lunch or dinner, but despite its universal appeal, the best pizzas can be crafted in a variety of distinct styles, sometimes creating an argument for which type of crust is superior. Ultimately, whether you’re a New York fan, Neapolitan aficionado or deep-dish diehard, pizza invites everyone back to the table again with its feel-good, undeniably delicious, let’s-have-a-pizza-party reputation.
Where to Find the Best Pizzas in the Springs
So where do you find the best pizzas in Colorado Springs? There’s no shortage of local pizza restaurants. These are our picks for Top 10 pizzas in in the Springs.
Pizzeria Rustica
Considered by many as a gem in Old Colorado City, this Italian-inspired pizzeria crafts Neapolitan pies in the traditional method, baked in a wood-fired oven that was made by a Colorado Springs mason. Following the Neapolitan process to prepare the dough, Pizzeria Rustica incorporates a special twist by blending imported Italian flour with organic Colorado whole wheat flour, prepared by hand every day. There is a strong emphasis on artisanal toppings, organically and sustainably sourced whenever possible, paired with an impressive selection of wine and beer, all at approachable price points.
Location: Old Colorado City
pizzeriarustica.com
Slice420
This New York-style pizza parlor serves gourmet pies and slices to patrons on both sides of Colorado Springs, with its OG location in Old Colorado City, and a colorful east-side shop with ample seating. The high-quality ingredients, thin-crust presentation and oversized slices make this a must for NY pizza lovers. (It was a standout when we wrote about the Best New York Style Pizza in the Springs.) Although Slice420 does not sell infused foods, their mission statement to acknowledge the health benefits of medical marijuana is stamped right on their pizza box. Co-owners Christian and Stefany moved to Colorado to gain access to THC, which has been a life-changing treatment for their daughter, who suffers from epilepsy and cerebral palsy.
Two Locations: Old Colorado City and Oro Blanco
slice420.com
High Rise Pizza Kitchen
For family pizza night this casual dine-in or carryout spot in the Rockrimmon area is clutch for its unique, locally sourced ingredients, handmade dough and a list of chef specialty pies that rotate seasonally. Plus, they have great meatballs, fresh salads and tasty garlic knots to add on to your order.
Location: Rockrimmon
highrisepizzakitchen.com
Basil & Barley
Basil & Barley on the north side of Colorado Springs brilliantly showcases Neapolitan-style pizza by adhering to precise specifications when kneading, resting and stretching the dough before baking their pies in a 1,000-degree oven that was imported from Naples, Italy. They serve both traditional Neapolitan classics plus some “game changers,” exclusive signature pies. You can also choose from an alternate gluten-free crust or one featuring added USA organic charcoal powder.
Location: Briargate
basilandbarley.com
Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse
With three destinations in Colorado Springs, out east, down south and up north, pizza lovers can find thin-crust pizza, bold wings and an exciting lineup of craft beers on tap in almost every corner of town. We gravitate toward the accommodating Interquest Parkway location with killer mountain views on their upstairs patio, a huge bar area and delectable New York-style pizza for dine-in, take-out or delivery.
Locations: Interquest, Powers, Ivywild
parryspizza.com
Leon Gessi New York Pizza
Locally and family-owned and operated since 1974, this old-school pizzeria is no frills and acts as the perfect destination for anyone looking to find a classic pie that looks, tastes and smells like its traditionally inspired New York pizza. The quaint pizzeria is located in the center of town on Palmer Park Boulevard. It will satisfy a craving for homemade ingredients and a cozy atmosphere that delivers pure pizza nostalgia.
Location: Central, Palmer Park and Union Boulevards
leongessipizza.com
White Pie
You’ll find this chic pizzeria in downtown Colorado Springs on South Nevada Avenue, with a modern aesthetic and a wide, inviting patio space. The open-air kitchen allows for wafts of breadiness to filter into the restaurant. The pies are New Haven and Sicilian style (featuring a sourdough starter), and along with common pizza toppings, you’ll find some unique options available, including creme fraiche, mashed potatoes, egg and butternut squash. The inventive menu also includes elevated cocktails, sought-after starters and divine desserts.
Location: Downtown
whitepie.com
Walter’s303
One of four Front Range locations, this north-side Colorado Springs pizzeria is situated near the Flying Horse neighborhood, carving out a home for the “always funky, never dull vibe” the casual restaurant and taphouse promotes. A great family-friendly locale or place to meet up with friends, Walter’s is known for an extensive list of craft beers and customizable pizzas in their signature hand-tossed style, thin crust, deep dish, gluten free or cauliflower crust.
Location: Flying Horse
walters303.com
Stellina Pizza Cafe
With picture-perfect placement in the heart of the historic Middle Shooks Run Neighborhood, Stellina welcomes guests with a full menu of Italian cuisine that highlights Roman-style pizza. The focused list of a half-dozen pies (which serve two to three people) distinguishes itself from other pizzas in Colorado Springs with a slightly bubbled up crust, oblong-rectangular shape and specialty ingredients like mini meatballs and ricotta. We highly recommend dining in to complete your experience with a handcrafted cocktail during happy hour (3-5 p.m., Tuesday-Friday) and a scoop of their delicious gelato.
Location: Shooks Run
stellinapizza.co
Pies & Grinders
Since opening its doors in 2001 with a humble carryout and delivery spot in Black Forest, this made-to-order pizzeria has grown into two more locations, serving more Colorado Springs residents from Powers Center Point all the way up to Monument. Pies & Grinders is a staple for build-your-own or gourmet pies and calzones, using their proprietary dough and sauce recipes, made in-house daily. Also unique are their cheesy grinder sandwiches and CBD-infused pizza and wings.
Locations: Powers, Black Forest, Monument
piesandgrinders.com
Vote for the Best Pizzas in Colorado Springs
What’s your favorite local pizza? We asked. You voted. Here’s the list of People’s Choice Best Pizza in Colorado Springs.
Read More
What goes better than pizza and beer? Here are our Best Breweries in Colorado Springs.
Don’t forget dessert! Find Sweet Treats: The Best Ice Cream in Colorado Springs.
And who doesn’t love brunch? Don’t miss these Best Brunches in the Springs.
